Yes,I prefer butt plugs if want to leave them in for extended anal play.I have kept a plug in for the entire day! Dildos are great for riding them in and out while you cum from the pounding!!!

Both

Both. But each is different. Start with a small butt plug, and just wear it, for a few hours, to relax your anus.
Dildos, are for later, when you want to feel more penetration, and in and out motions, when you have learned to relax your anal muscles.
Anal play, and even solo masturbation, anally, with a toy, can feel AMAZING, if you are relaxed, and ready, wanting it, and enjoying it.
A lot of guys tense up, with something going into their bottoms, as it seems unnatural, and 'wrong', but the Greeks and Romans did it, and it feels AMAZING, when you relax, and get it right, with a toy, or a trusted partner!!

Both

I had my large butt plug up my ass yesterday for about 4 hours

You all keep using dildos, and later in life you'll need a butt plug

Why limit yourself to one over the other, get both. (youre going to want to anyway, Ive found that putting different things in my ass is like potato chips....have one, youll wanna have more, )

[deleted image]
this is neither *lix*

a girlfriend with a strap on out ways anything but if you can't do that use her dildo

A big fat Dildo is the best but the sensation of pulling your plug out after a long day is amazing

Dildo is dangerous in the ass. It Can be swallowed in and then you need to go to the hospital.
--------------------------------------- added after 28 seconds

Buttplug is safe.

Get both.I have butt plugs in 1.5",1.75",2.0"These are great for opening the butthole,and can be left in for however long that you want.The dildos that I have are suction cup based and in sizes 1.5"x7",1.75"x9",2.0"x11" this last one really fills me up and gives new meaning to the phrase Deep Penetration!!!Talk about a hard prostate cum!!!

Get both of them.You could use butt plug for scretching and walking around home.And dildo is for anal play, self fucking and riding.

get both for sure

Get both. Each has its purpose.

giant dildo

buy both, and get a few different ones, theyre pretty cheap, spoil yourself *lix*

i like the pump up butt plugs. You can start out small then pump it up and boy what ride. it pushes on your prostate and you start to cum and cum and cum. the lady at the porn store sed that is a very good pic. one of her faves and mine too.

Yeah buy both toys.You will insert buttplug and could leave it there for a while to scretch you and you will use dildo when you get really horny and want to be fucked anally

Both.

I love to wear a plug when I am out in public . gives me the feeling I am getting away with something. It does dry out after awhile and I have to relube. I also have a large dildo that takes awhile to stretch out to fit. Just not like the real thing tho. I love the feeling of him cumming in me and knowing I gave him that much pleasure. Almost as much fun as cumming.

Get both.You can have the butt plug in all day to get yourself horny then when you get home fuck yourself with the dildo.

both. no need to decide between them. Both are fantastic fun and feel great.

I love a butt plug

This is really good....


...but I also like a long cold steel dildo with a round head. Excellent grunty cums!!!

whichever is available [deleted image]

I've used both [deleted image]
--------------------------------------- added after 47 seconds

And in the absence of either I use whatever available:
[deleted image]

I have both. Dildo for ass fucking and butt plug for contant feel of filled ass.

Get both!

Whatever it is, be careful.
only registered users can see external links

a dildo can be used for both needs it has more of a real feel to it 4 me

I like both just depends on what i want on any given day

She's fucking my ass with a dildo here.
[deleted image]

Butblug

Plug...if u like a challenge and a stretch. But rewards

Both.

Using an electric trimmer instead of a butt plug or dildo.
[deleted image]

I only have Dildos
[deleted image]