Smallish (~4 inches) and very erect.

Touch and taste followed by size and stiffness.

It is all about attitude and energy

I enjoy seeing all cocks but my favorite are soft uncut penises with lots of foreskin. The more the better!

Cocks were made for sucking! I love the feeling of a cock in my mouth. Locking my lips around the shaft. Feeling the head pop in and out of my mouth. And when a cock gets so hard and throbbing in my mouth it is incredible. The soon to be cumming explosive, pulsating, contractions and spewing of warm delicious cum is a sensation like no other. I enjoy sucking a cock as it softens after delivering a load of cum. If I am really lucky I'll feel that soft cock begin to grow and harden ready for another draining. Cocks were made for sucking and I love sucking cocks!

Everything from the balls to the big shot. Cocks are so beautiful

Beauty is in the eye of the beHOLDER. I hope that when you hold your own cock, you see it as beautiful.
[deleted image]
I honestly think that I find cocks that look similar to mine to be the most attractive to me. Is that true for others?

Cocks are beautiful. That said, some are more beautiful than others. I prefer a cut cock. The head is gorgeous and deserves to be displayed. A long shaft gives good proportion. (And the longer the shaft the longer the lick!) Balls also look appealing whether they are "tight" or hanging loose. I especially love seeing them bouncing either while wanked or sucked. What attracts me is the compulsion I have to get a cock into my mouth, suck it and swallow the warm, delicious cum. Cocks are made for sucking!

small, uncut (more skin the better), and flaccid!!!

Too veiny?! Head too big?! You've got to be kidding! Visible veins on the surface of the shaft are one of the things that makes a penis attractive. A nice good sized and well shaped glans is another.

OK, on to your question about what makes a penis attractive.

First of all, good proportion. The size of the glans should be well proportioned to the length and diameter of the shaft. You score at least a 9.5 there. Maybe even a ten.

Secondly, a well shaped "helmet head" glans. I'll give you a perfect ten on that.

Third, a nice straight shaft. A slight downward curve (such as yours) or a slight upward curve are satisfactory, but a sideways curve is serious points off. An upward curve is nice for sucking in the sixty-nine position while a downward curve is good for sucking in the kneeling position. With your slight downward curve I'll give you at least a nine, maybe a 9.5.

Visible veins on the surface of the shaft are not absolutely essential, but if they are there that's a nice plus.

Overall size of the penis is un-important. I've seen stunningly attractive micropenises and rather unattractive monster cocks. The qualities I mentioned above are what makes for an attractive penis.

All told, I'd give you penis at least a 9.5, perhaps a nine and three quarters. The only thing wrong with it is that it is not in my mouth.

A fat dick with a nice big head and big nuts

For me, I find a cock sexy when there is zero pubic hair. Not only does the removal of the hair make the cock look bigger, but it also makes it look more smooth. And if there is either precum or sperm coming out, it's just the icing on the cake.